Critical friends in school leadership: a case study of the development of departmental heads in high schools.

Abstract

In the intricate tapestry of human connections lies a unique facet: critical friendships. These alliances, characterised by trust, guidance, and diverse perspectives, hold particular relevance in school leadership, notably for Departmental Heads (DHs). This study explores Critical Friends (CFs) within high school leadership, drawing from Transformational Leadership Theory and Transformative Learning Theory, tracing their historical underpinnings and evolution. Utilising a case study methodology, this research pursues three primary objectives: firstly, identifying the contributors to DHs development as CFs; secondly, exploring the expansion of CF networks among DHs; and lastly, delineating the leadership domains where CF guidance is sought. Using semi-structured interviews and Metaphorical Photo-Elicitation (MPE), this case study delves into the dynamics of CFs in school leadership. Purposeful sampling ensures a mosaic of insights, capturing the kaleidoscope of participant perspectives. The findings of the case study further identify pivotal elements imperative for the cultivating and sustaining of CF networks. Among these elements, participants underscored the indispensability of listening skills, confidentiality, and honesty within such relationships. Trust emerges as a cornerstone in critical friendships, intricately intertwined with the practice of active listening. Participants in the study highlighted the pivotal role CFs play in supporting school improvement initiatives, particularly in low-performing schools, as observed in both research schools. DHs expressed engaging with CFs to strategise and implement approaches aimed at elevating their schools from the low-performance zone. This exploration serves to spotlight the indispensable role of CFs in the landscape of school leadership development, shedding light on their multifaceted contributions to growth, transformation, and resilience in DHs.