<link rel="stylesheet" href="styles.cf390c6bfbe7555f.css">
 

ResearchSpace

ResearchSpace is the institutional repository of the University of KwaZulu-Natal,
unlocking knowledge, empowering impact, and preserving UKZN's research legacy.

 
 
 
 
 

Recent Submissions

  • Item type:Item,
    Blood transfusions: medical treatment or operation. Challenges encountered when balancing autonomy and religious beliefs with best interest standards.
    (2024) Ghila, Nitinkumar Mohan.; McQuoid-Mason, David Jan.
    Blood transfusions remain a cornerstone of modern medical practice and are an essential component in the management of patients in almost every field of clinical practice. There may be numerous challenges and requirements when blood transfusions are administered. It is therefore imperative to have a full comprehension of the legal aspects of administering a blood transfusion and how this may impact on adults and children. Prior to the commencement of any treatment, the patient needs to be part of the decision-making process. This mini-dissertation involves desktop research including both primary and secondary sources, on the legal and constitutional aspects of administering a blood transfusion. The rights based on religious beliefs and the right to refuse blood transfusions are discussed in the context of Jehovah’s Witnesses. While acknowledgement is given to parents’ rights to parenting and their rights to religious freedom and beliefs, the rights of children with rights to life, human dignity, healthcare, family or parental care must be balanced with the best interest standards. The study explores the rights of adults compared to children from the common law and constitutional aspects of consent and the autonomy of children in decision-making. It is conspicuous that the drafters of the Children’s Act did not provide a clear delineation between medical and surgical treatment, a deficiency that carries substantial implications for the legal framework governing children’s capacity to provide informed consent. A recommendation is made to address this deficiency in terms of amendments to section 129(3) of the Children’s Act to include invasive treatment. Furthermore, amendments to the Children’s Act should be made to include invasive procedures in subsections 129(5) to 129(10) alongside medical treatment and surgical operations, to enhance clarity and strengthen the protection of children’s rights and best interests.
  • Item type:Item,
    The implications of artificial womb technology on the right to terminate pregnancy.
    (2023) Balmint, Akeera.; Soni, Sheetal Jacqueline.
    This study investigates the implications, if any, of artificial womb technology on the current legal framework in South Africa, with particular regard to the legal framework for termination of pregnancy. Artificial womb technology has developed significantly throughout the years and will one day offer an alternative method for individuals to reproduce. The word ectogenesis has been used to define a pregnancy that has started or completed in an artificial womb. Partial ectogenesis is a form of this technology where a fetus is transferred from a womb in which it was developing to an artificial womb to continue the gestational period. This may be in cases where the continued gestation would prove to be harmful or life-threatening for the individual carrying the fetus, or the fetus itself. There have been promising animal studies demonstrating that partial ectogenesis is possible. Complete ectogenesis refers to where a fetus does not develop in a womb, and completes its entire gestation in an artificial womb. There have been no studies on complete ectogenesis yet, and therefore this will not be explored in this dissertation. Since the fetus will be developing ex utero, it is unclear as to how the current law should be interpreted. Reproductive autonomy in light of reproductive technologies in its application must ensure that it does not unjustifiably infringe on the reproductive rights of women and additionally creates an equilibrium between the rights and interests of both the fetus and the mother. However, it is crucial to ascertain whether the fetus will be afforded legal rights as in terms of partial ectogenesis, it continues developing ex utero and independent of the mother. This will also affect the Section 12(2) of the Constitution concerning the bodily and psychological integrity of one’s own body in the instance where the fetus will no longer be in the womb of the woman. It will be shown that the Choice of Termination of Pregnancy Act 92 of 1996 will not be applicable in cases of partial ectogenesis. The right to terminate pregnancy within the parameters of that statute remain uneroded, as gestation in an artificial womb is not contemplated as a ‘pregnancy’ in the Act. The potential of artificial wombs to reduce infant mortality rates is theoretically high and is significant in the instance where a fetus is underdeveloped and exercises no independent capacity of life. However, in this dissertation it is imperative to clarify several legal issues relating to a gestation that is taking place ex utero in an artificial womb.
  • Item type:Item,
    Exploring the approaches of a community education and training college in creating and managing community partnerships for quality service learning.
    (2026) Nsele, Nomalanga Ntokozo.; Chikoko, Vitallis.
    This case study sought to explore the approaches of a community education and training (CET) college in KwaZulu-Natal, in creating and managing community partnerships for quality service learning. The study explored the perspectives of two centre managers, five lecturers from two community learning centres and two partnership unit managers from the community college . The study was conducted within the confines of interpretive paradigm . Data were generated using semi-structured individual interviews, which data was thematically analysed. The transformational leadership theory was adopted as the theoretical framework for this study. The study discovered that the formation of service-learning partnerships in the CET college is not organised into a defined, transparent structure. It demonstrates that, while relationships have been established with many stakeholders for service learning, there is a lack of coherence in the administration of such collaborations. The centre managers and lecturers do not have a comprehensive understanding of how to formally establish, administer, monitor, and record the centre-community created partnerships. As a result, there is a lack of clarity on partnership management roles and expectations. The study again found that formal and funded partnerships applications are centralised in the college partnership unit on behalf of the community learning centres (CLCs) even without their knowledge. Resourcing of centre community engagements and learning support material are centralised in the college central office and there is no centre financial management capacity. To achieve and be effective, change requires strong leadership and management influence. The study recommends that all centre managers take part in training intervention programmes such as workshops, short business and leadership courses, mentorships, and seminars on the application, formation, and management of formal and funded service-learning partnerships. The CET college should evaluate its standard procedure for CLC funding norms in terms of centre-sourced funding. CLCs must be empowered and allowed to enter contracts for financial gain, and centre managers must be taught in financial management and reporting. The study further recommends the concept of change management be applied to allow for a more transparent andcollaborative approach to the creation and management of college-community service-learning partnerships for quality responsive learning.
  • Item type:Item,
    Creating working collaborations between teachers and SGB members: a multi-stakeholder perspective.
    (2026) Narayan, Jesmika.; Myende, Phumlani Erasmus.
    This study explores how working collaborations are created among teachers and members of school governing bodies (SGBs) in the context of South African schools. Focusing on three secondary schools situated in the iLembe district of the beautiful province of KwaZulu-Natal in South Africa, the main aim was to explore the characteristics associated with the meaning of working collaborations while also identifying how these meanings are interpreted. The research further explores the factors that facilitate and hamper working collaborations between teachers and SGBs. While existing literature offers some insight into this area, gaps remain in understanding the factors that contribute to successful collaborations. To address this disparity, the study employed the Collegial Model as its analytical framework. A qualitative approach and an interpretivist paradigm were employed, and purposive sampling was used to identify 15 participants, which included post level 1 teachers, departmental heads, SGB chairpersons and members from the parent component of the SGB. Data was collected through semi-structured interviews, and document review enhanced this. Reflections by participants highlighted meaning, associated with working collaborations, while their insights revealed how these collaborations are construed, along with the factors that obstruct and endorse collaborations among school stakeholders. The findings emphasised that SGB members feel overwhelmed and disempowered, mainly because they do not fully understand their duties. The study identified three key findings. First, there is a need for the Department of Basic Education to provide more training for SGB members. Second, it is important that principals actively perform their duties with fairness and without bias. Third, regular meetings between teachers and SGB members are essential to strengthen collaboration and communication. Based on these findings, it is suggested that strategies be put in place to enhance working collaborations between these school stakeholders. Successful, fully developed working collaborations between teachers and SGB members will undoubtedly benefit learners and allow schools to reach their full potential.
  • Item type:Item,
    A comparative analysis of the media representation of Cyril Ramaphosa and Jacob Zuma’s leadership qualities in the Sunday times and Mail & guardian: a pre-during and post-2024 general elections study.
    (2026) Ngema, Nompumelelo Luyanda.; Jones, Nicola-Jane.
    The online press plays an important role in shaping public discourse and representations of political leaders, particularly during periods of electoral contestation. Existing research has demonstrated the significance of media framing in constructing public representations of political actors and their leadership qualities. However, less attention has been given to how culturally constructed frames are used to represent leadership qualities and how these representations change across different stages of an electoral process. This study therefore examines the media representation of Cyril Ramaphosa and Jacob Zuma in the Mail & Guardian and Sunday Times during the pre-election, election and postelection periods of the 2024 South African general elections. The study draws primarily on Van Gorp's constructionist approach to framing and Foucault's conceptualisation of discourse, power and knowledge to examine how culturally available meanings are incorporated into media representations of political leadership. A qualitative research approach was adopted, using a comparative case study design and qualitative analysis of online news articles. An initial search identified 119 relevant articles, of which 59 met the established inclusion criteria and were retained for analysis. The data were analysed through thematic analysis, framing analysis and critical discourse analysis to identify recurring patterns in the representation of the two political leaders. The findings identified six broad culturally constructed frames: Tolerance and Zero-Tolerance to Corruption, Constitutional Accountability, Authoritarian Leadership, Collaborative Leadership, Electoral Representation and Unity. The study found that the Mail & Guardian and Sunday Times employed broadly similar frames in their coverage, although differences were evident in the emphasis, tone and contextual application of these frames to Ramaphosa and Zuma. The findings further demonstrate that the representations and prominence of particular frames changed across the pre-election, election and post-election periods as the political context developed. The study contributes to scholarship on media framing, political leadership and media representation by demonstrating how culturally constructed meanings are used to make particular leadership qualities salient within political news discourse. It further contributes to understanding the relationship between media, political leadership and democratic discourse in contemporary South Africa by showing how the representation of political leaders is shaped by the interaction between political events, cultural meanings and journalistic discourse.