A comparative socio-economic impact assessment of the Covid-19 pandemic on tourism small, medium and micro enterprises (SMMEs) in coastal cities: case studies of Cape Town and Durban, South Africa.
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
Tourism businesses at specific destinations play a strategic role across the tourism value chain, contributing to job creation and local economic development. The economic downturn associated with Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) had and continues to have severe implications for the tourism sector that came to a halt as global and national travel was curtailed to control the spread of the virus. Coastal and Marine Tourism (CMT) sites in South Africa are regarded as the form of tourism, which has the highest demand with the largest concentration of Small, Medium and Micro Enterprises (SMMEs). The reasons for the focus on SMMEs are twofold: they make up the majority of the businesses in the tourism sector, and they are most vulnerable to disruptions. While there has been an increase in research on the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic on businesses, there is limited research on CMT businesses that adopts a comparative approach. Cape Town and Durban were purposively chosen because they are key CMT destinations. A theoretical framework that combines stakeholder theory, diffusion theory (including Sen’s capabilities framework), and Drivers, Pressures, State, Impacts and Responses (DPSIR) is utilized. In this framework, SMMEs are considered the primary stakeholders, which is the focus of this study. Furthermore, diffusion theory is employed to analyze the SMMEs’ ability and potential to adapt to change. What capabilities tourism SMMEs have and which are critical to enable successful responsiveness to the COVID-19 pandemic is a key focus of the study. The capabilities approach provides the framework to assess the impacts of new and emerging technologies that have characterized responses to the COVID-19 pandemic. The DPSIR model provides a useful approach to examine internal and external (the COVID-19 pandemic being a major externality) drivers and pressures that impact tourism SMMEs and the factors that influence the responses. A mixed methods methodological approach was adopted, including a desktop component, a quantitative survey targeting tourism SMMEs in Cape Town and Durban, and key informant interviews. Specifically, for the quantitative survey, 446 surveys were conducted with SMMEs at purposively selected beach/ CMT locations in Cape Town (219) and Durban (227), which enabled a comparative analysis to be undertaken. Twelve key informant interviews were completed with relevant government department officials, representatives from tourism and small business organizations, and academic researchers. Parts of the primary data used in this study were from a larger National Department of Tourism (NDT) funded research project titled ‘Enabling SMMEs Survival and Growth During/ Post COVID-19’. The findings indicate that tourism SMMEs offer several products and services, being involved in a wide range of activities, which is reflective of the diversity of the tourism landscape and value chain in South Africa. The study’s primary findings indicate significant differences in the profiles of SMMEs based on factors such as location, turnover, business formality, employee count, and years in operation that affect the SMMEs’ capabilities and responses to cope with the COVID-19 disruptions. Tourism SMMEs experienced both operational and disruption risks, with the COVID-19 pandemic being the disruption risk that triggered numerous operational risks. The responses indicate most SMMEs interviewed faced multiple and severe COVID-19 pandemic disruptions, with most indicating decreases in sales/ demand for goods and services as well as cash flow availability, denoting the dominance of financial challenges. Various SMMEs adopted diverse tools and measures to deal with the pandemic, including employee changes, organizational adjustments, and financial changes, with most of the responses being reactive and unplanned and not being innovative. However, most businesses indicated that they will continue to change their operations even when the pandemic is under control. The results demonstrate that the impact of COVID-19 varied across different types of SMMEs and at different locations, with those in Cape Town adopting more strategies and being more likely to recover sooner. Those SMMEs with limited resources and support were more vulnerable. Additionally, some types of businesses were forced to implement strategies such as retrenchments and utilizing personal and business savings, leaving them more vulnerable in the future. The lack of capabilities and high levels of vulnerability, especially among micro-enterprises, implies that these businesses are unlikely to be able to adapt to changing consumer demands and increased disruptions. Financial support emerged as being critically important to support tourism SMMEs and despite challenges experienced by the government, there was consensus that they were best positioned to provide the support. Most of the tourism SMMEs that secured government support viewed it as being beneficial. Most tourism SMMEs either were not aware of government support or felt that they did not qualify for the support offered. For most variables examined, differences were noted between Cape Town and Durban indicating that place matters when examining the impacts of disruptions on tourism SMMEs. The study recommends interventions such as providing funding and supporting training to better position tourism SMMEs to be resilient in a world where disruptions are likely to be experienced more regularly in the face of climate change and economic recessions. As the recovery of the tourism sector resumes, drivers that were prominent before the COVID-19 pandemic (including destination reputation, increased tourism consumption, and the expectation for diverse and new tourism products and services) will need to be integrated into recovery and long-term sustainability plans for the sector with promoting tourism, especially domestic tourism via the implementation of the domestic Tourism Scheme, being central. To build greater resilience and capabilities to deal with future disruptions it is important to create enabling conditions for tourism demand to grow sustainably and for tourism SMMEs to be responsive and prepared. A resiliency framework is proposed that includes a vulnerability assessment of tourism SMMEs to provide a vulnerability index. A funding framework is also recommended to provide financial support in an efficient and accountable manner that is not reliant solely on government support that assists tourism SMMEs to cope with major disruptions/ crises. Effective communication and awareness strategies as well as training are also advocated. The variations among tourism SMMEs, especially understanding the vulnerability profiles of tourism SMMEs at specific locations, are critical to consider since they are likely to influence the strategies used to respond to disruptions and build resilience that strengthens the tourism sector.
Description
Doctoral Degree. University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban.
Keywords
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as CC0 1.0 Universal

