Road entry point management systems and and regional integration : the case of Zimbabwe.
Loading...
Date
2016
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
Regions face integration impediments, yet despite statistics showing some regions making
significant strides toward integration, the Southern African Development Community (SADC) lags
behind. The management and administration of road entry points between national borders is critical
for regional integration (RI), despite entry points being associated with safeguarding state
sovereignty. SADC’s intraregional trade is predominantly undertaken by road, thus an empirical
inquiry into road entry point management systems (REPMS) is necessary, as little research has been
done on them. REPMS and public administration support or hinder trade facilitation; non-tariff
barriers (NTBs) tend to hinder RI, particularly administrative disincentives to export which translate
into cost of doing business.
Through the lens of Zimbabwe, this study aims to determine the relationship between REPMS and
NTBs by comparatively examining the Zambia-Zimbabwe Chirundu one-stop-border-post (OSBP)
and three two-stop-border posts (TSBPs) between Zimbabwe and Botswana, Mozambique and South
Africa. Critical realism philosophy is used to interrogate the extent to which neo-functionalist and
modernisation theories explain the relationship between RI, NTBs, REPMS and state sovereignty.
The participants in this mixed method research study included a total of 12 interviewees who were
drawn from various Zimbabwean ministries, namely Industry and Commerce; Finance/Revenue
Authority; Small and Medium Enterprises and Development. Truck drivers and small and mediumsized
entrepreneurs made up the 378 survey respondents, and secondary data were also used. The
combined sampling strategies included subgroup census, convenience and purposive. The qualitative
data were analysed through a thematic and matrix analysis, whilst the quantitative data were
analysed with Stata 11.0.
The findings suggest that NTBs at TSBPs lead to delays, corruption, and increased costs, yet
inefficient management systems at OSBPs cause the latter to be as administratively ineffective as the
former. Statistically significant relationships were found to be between REPMS, NTBs and trade
encouragement; and single clearance processes conducted by the country of exit or entry. Neither the
neo-functionalist nor the modernisation theories adequately explained the relationships between
variables. The data showed that state sovereignty impedes RI; that colonial legacies bedevil the
region; and that harmonisation of administrative procedures, whether OSBPs or TSBPs, could help
facilitate trade and RI. Recommendations and conclusions are thus proffered, and a new theoretical
model beyond the neo-functionalist or modernisation approaches to RI is presented.
Description
Doctor of Philosophy in Management and Public Administration. University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban 2016.