The relationship between novice physical sciences teachers’ beliefs and goals to inquiry-based instruction.

Abstract

Inquiry-Based Instruction (IBI) has been positively associated with quality science education for the past 50 years. Research studies in science education cite beliefs and goals as the main reasons for the lack of IBI in science classrooms. Nevertheless, previous attempts to understand the reasons for this lack of IBI revealed a mismatch between science teachers’ beliefs to classroom practices. The research gap on improving physical sciences teachers’ IBI practices persists despite studies on teachers’ beliefs to classroom practices. This gap in the literature and continued use of traditional instruction have motivated this study to ascertain the impact of beliefs and goals in classroom practices. Framed by the constructivist learning theory and goal-driven teacher cognition model, this study explored the relationship between novice physical sciences teachers’ beliefs and goals to IBI practices. From a goal-driven theory of cognition perspective, teachers’ actions are an attempt to satisfy one or more of the goals they hold. This multiple qualitative case study was couched within the constructivist research paradigm. Four novice physical sciences teachers were purposively selected to participate in the study. Data were collected through multiple sources, including three open-ended questionnaires (TBI, POSTT, TGI), classroom observations, stimulated-recall interviews, collected artefacts, and field notes. The findings of this study revealed that despite the curriculum advocating IBI, novice physical sciences teachers’ enactment is at a low level, teacher-centred in their classrooms. Findings suggest that IBI practice is facilitated by mediating teaching and learning beliefs with environmental factors for goal adoption. They further provide evidence suggesting that the goals teachers pursue are influenced by their teaching and learning beliefs and their schools’ environmental factors. Among the key lessons from this study is that it is essential to help physical sciences teachers develop and pursue beliefs and goals that characterise IBI practices that have the potential to improve science education. This study provides several implications for teacher education and research.